Score Your Recruitment Agency's AI Visibility in 4 Minutes
Score your recruitment agency's AI visibility in four minutes with Kaizen SEO's free AI Visibility Scorecard. It asks 19 questions across four pillars, then runs a live check against ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews. The average recruitment site in Kaizen SEO's teardowns scores 38 out of 100.
Key Takeaways
- AI visibility is the likelihood that ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or Google AI Overviews name your agency when a client asks who to call.
- Kaizen SEO's AI Visibility Scorecard scores four pillars separately, Findability, Citability, Foundations and Proof.
- The average recruitment site in Kaizen SEO's AI Visibility Teardowns scores 38 out of 100.
- G2's April 2026 research found 85% of B2B software buyers think more highly of a vendor when AI includes it in an answer.
- Technical gaps behind weak Foundations scores usually clear inside 30 days once a developer has the list.
What AI Visibility Means for a Recruitment Agency
AI visibility is the likelihood an AI engine names your agency when someone asks who the best recruiters are for a role or sector. It's separate from Google rankings. An agency can rank well and still go unnamed in ChatGPT, Gemini or a Google AI Overview.
That separation matters for new business. G2's Answer Economy report, based on 1,076 B2B software buyers in April 2026, found 85% think more highly of a vendor when AI includes it in an answer. Being named builds trust before the first call.
Why does AI visibility differ from Google rankings?
AI engines choose sources differently from Google's ranked list. Each engine retrieves pages its own way and favours pages with clear, quotable answers and outside proof. A page built only to rank can lack the direct statements an AI engine needs before it names a firm.
Do hiring managers use AI to find recruiters?
Hiring managers use the same AI tools for suppliers that buyers use for software. G2's April 2026 survey found 51% of B2B software buyers start research with an AI chatbot more often than with Google. Our piece on clients asking ChatGPT to shortlist recruiters shows what those answers look like.
The Four Pillars the Scorecard Measures
The scorecard measures four pillars and scores each one separately, so the weakest stands out. An agency's total can look fine while one pillar quietly keeps it out of AI answers. The split is what tells you where to start.
What does Findability measure?
Findability scores whether your agency ranks for the commercial searches clients actually type. It covers sector pages, city pages and the keyword positions behind them. A low Findability score means hiring managers searching your niche rarely reach your site at all.
What does Citability measure?
Citability scores whether AI engines name your agency when someone asks who the best recruiters are. The live check queries ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews against your domain for your sector, then reports which engines named you.
What does Foundations measure?
Foundations covers whether your site can be read, crawled and trusted. Broken job pages, missing structured data, slow templates and blocked crawlers all pull the score down. Kaizen SEO finds these gaps usually clear inside 30 days once a developer has the list.
What does Proof measure?
Proof scores whether your content shows real sector expertise rather than a feed of live roles. Case studies, placement data, consultant profiles and market commentary lift it. A site that's mostly job ads gives AI engines nothing to say about your expertise, which is why the content that wins employer clients matters here too.
What the Average Score Tells You
The average recruitment site scores 38 out of 100 across Kaizen SEO's AI Visibility Teardowns. Most agencies are missing from AI answers for at least some of their own commercial searches. A score above average isn't safety, because one weak pillar can still hide an agency from a whole engine.
The most useful reading is the gap between pillars. Strong Findability with weak Citability means you rank but don't get named, which is the rank to citation gap. Strong Proof with weak Foundations means good content that crawlers struggle to read.
What's a good AI visibility score for a recruiter?
Anything above the 38 average puts an agency ahead of the typical site Kaizen SEO checks, but the pillar split matters more than the total. Fix the weakest pillar first, because one weak pillar can keep your agency out of a whole engine's answers.
How to Score and Improve Your Recruitment Agency's AI Visibility
- Step 1. Take the AI Visibility Scorecard and answer the 19 questions about your site, content and proof.
- Step 2. Read the report, which arrives by email within minutes with a score for each pillar and your weakest pillar named.
- Step 3. Check the live results and note which of the four AI engines named your agency.
- Step 4. Send technical fixes to your developer and content work to whoever owns your site copy.
- Step 5. Fix the weakest pillar first, because one weak pillar holds the whole score down.
- Step 6. Retake the scorecard after 90 days to measure the change.
Our guide to answer engine optimisation for recruiters explains the content side of Steps 4 and 5. Our guide on getting cited in AI search goes deeper on Citability. For the full service, see AI visibility for recruitment agencies.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the AI Visibility Scorecard?
The AI Visibility Scorecard is Kaizen SEO's free 19 question assessment for recruitment agencies. It scores Findability, Citability, Foundations and Proof, runs a live check against four AI engines and emails a report within minutes. It costs nothing and doesn't need a call beforehand.
How long does the AI visibility check take?
The AI Visibility Scorecard takes about four minutes, which is the average completion time. The report arrives by email within minutes of finishing. It scores each pillar separately, names your weakest pillar and shows which AI engines named your agency in the live check.
Which AI engines does the scorecard check?
The scorecard checks ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews. The live check queries each engine against your domain for your sector and reports whether your agency was named. Results often differ by engine, because each one retrieves and selects its sources in its own way.
What is a good AI visibility score for a recruitment agency?
A good AI visibility score sits above the recruitment average of 38 out of 100 from Kaizen SEO's teardowns. The total matters less than the weakest pillar. An agency strong on Findability but weak on Citability ranks on Google yet goes unnamed in AI answers.
How do I improve my agency's AI visibility?
Improve AI visibility by fixing the weakest pillar first. Foundations gaps usually clear within 30 days through technical fixes. Citability and Proof improve with direct answers, case studies and placement data on money pages. Retake the scorecard after 90 days to measure the progress made.
About the Author
Dan Jones is the founder and SEO lead at Kaizen SEO, a recruitment SEO and AI visibility consultancy based in Staffordshire. He worked as a recruiter before moving into search, and has spent more than 10 years running SEO for specialist agencies. Kaizen SEO is the only UK recruitment SEO consultancy founded by a former recruiter. Connect with Dan on LinkedIn.
Get your score now. Take the free AI Visibility Scorecard. It's 19 questions and about four minutes, and your report names the pillar costing you the most.