07.11.26

5 Recruitment Website Faults Generalist SEO Agencies Miss

Generalist SEO agencies miss five recruitment website faults because they've never worked a recruitment desk. Broken apply flows, expired job pages, missing job markup, mixed client and candidate pages and thin consultant profiles all cost placements. Kaizen SEO was founded by a former recruiter, and these are the faults it checks first.

Key Takeaways

  • Recruitment websites carry faults general business sites don't, because they run live job feeds, two audiences and constant vacancy turnover.
  • Google's job posting guidance says closed jobs must carry a past validThrough date, return a 404 or 410, or lose their markup, and warns slow action can lead to a manual action.
  • Apply buttons that route to a generic contact form lose candidates, and the ones who finish arrive with no role attached.
  • Pages that mix client and candidate messages weaken rankings and AI citations for both audiences.
  • 3Search Group went from 4 to 359 top 10 keywords in 10 months after a migration Kaizen SEO managed.

Why Generalist SEO Agencies Miss These Faults

Generalist SEO agencies miss these faults because their checklists are built for brochure sites and ecommerce. A recruitment site behaves differently. It can publish and expire hundreds of job pages a year, serves two audiences and runs on an ATS or job feed the SEO agency rarely touches.

A standard audit crawls the site, flags slow pages and missing meta descriptions, then stops. It won't click Apply on a live vacancy. It won't check what happens to a job page after the role closes. Those are the checks that find lost placements.

How is recruitment SEO different from regular SEO?

Recruitment SEO deals with live job feeds, two audiences and vacancy turnover that regular SEO never meets. A generalist optimises static service pages. A specialist also manages job markup, expired listings, ATS integrations and separate journeys for hiring managers and candidates, as our guide to how recruitment SEO differs from regular SEO sets out.

The Five Faults

These five faults show up across recruitment sites of every size. None of them appear in a design review. All of them cost candidates, clients or both.

What happens when Apply buttons go to a generic contact form?

Candidates drop out. A candidate clicks Apply on a specific role and lands on a homepage form with no job reference. Many give up, and those who finish arrive with no role attached, so a consultant has to chase them. Every vacancy needs an apply flow tied to that role.

Why do expired job pages hurt a recruitment site?

Expired job pages leave dead links and closed roles in Google's index. Google's job posting guidance says closed jobs need a past validThrough date, a 404 or 410 status, or removed markup. Failure to act in time may result in a manual action.

What does missing job markup cost a recruiter?

Missing JobPosting markup keeps vacancies out of Google's job search experience. Google can't read the title, location, salary and closing date as structured fields. The role still exists on your site, but candidates searching inside Google's job listings never see it. Our Google for Jobs setup guide covers the fix.

Why do mixed client and candidate pages fail?

Mixed pages fail because they answer two intents at once. A hiring manager looking for an agency and a candidate looking for work need different content. When one page tries to serve both, Google and AI engines struggle to match it cleanly to either search. A site built for two audiences fixes it.

What should a recruitment consultant profile include?

A consultant profile should include the sector covered, years in that market, the roles placed and a named result or testimonial. Hiring managers check the consultant before taking a BD call. A photo and two generic lines give them nothing to trust.

What These Faults Cost in Placements

These faults cost placements on both sides of the desk. Apply flow and job feed faults cut applications. Page structure and profile faults cut briefs. Because each fault sits in a different part of the site, no single report shows the total damage.

Specialist work pays. 3Search Group went from 4 to 359 top 10 keywords in 10 months after a migration Kaizen SEO managed, according to Kaizen SEO's case study.

Can a web designer fix recruitment SEO problems?

A web designer can fix layout and speed, but most recruitment SEO faults sit in job feeds, markup and page structure. Those need someone who understands ATS integrations, JobPosting markup and two-audience site architecture. Design reviews rarely test apply flows or expired listings at all.

How to Check Your Recruitment Website for These Faults

  1. Step 1. Click Apply on three live jobs and check each one lands on a form tied to that role.
  2. Step 2. Open five closed vacancies and confirm each returns a 404 or 410, or shows a past closing date.
  3. Step 3. Test a live vacancy URL in Google's Rich Results Test and check the JobPosting markup is valid.
  4. Step 4. Review your sector pages and move any candidate content to candidate pages.
  5. Step 5. Audit every consultant profile for sector, experience and a named result.
  6. Step 6. Fix in order of cost, starting with the apply flow, then expired jobs, markup, page structure and profiles.

For a wider view, our guide to what separates a specialist recruitment SEO agency covers what to look for in outside help. For the full service, see our recruitment SEO page.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if my job pages are indexed properly?

Check job pages in Search Console's Pages report, then search Google's job listings for a live role. If a current vacancy doesn't appear, test its URL in the Rich Results Test. Missing or invalid JobPosting markup is one of the most common causes on recruitment sites.

What happens if you leave expired job pages live?

Expired job pages left live show closed roles in Google's job search, frustrate candidates and create thin, duplicate pages. Google warns that failing to expire jobs in time may result in a manual action. Expire them with a past validThrough date, a 404 or 410, or removed markup.

Should a recruitment agency use a specialist SEO agency?

A recruitment agency gets faster results from a specialist, because the most common faults are sector-specific. Kaizen SEO was founded by a former recruiter and works only with recruitment firms. Generalists can handle basics, but they rarely test apply flows, job feeds or client page structure.

Which recruitment website fault should I fix first?

Fix the apply flow first, because it loses candidates who've already chosen a role. Expired job pages come next, since Google can take manual action on them. JobPosting markup, page structure and consultant profiles follow, in that order of cost to the agency.

How long does it take to fix these recruitment website faults?

Most of these faults are technical and clear within weeks once a developer has the list. Kaizen SEO finds technical gaps like these usually clear inside 30 days. Consultant profiles and page restructuring take longer, because they need input from the consultants themselves.

About the Author

Dan Jones is the founder and SEO lead at Kaizen SEO, a recruitment SEO and AI visibility consultancy based in Staffordshire. He worked as a recruiter before moving into search, and has spent more than 10 years running SEO for specialist agencies. Kaizen SEO is the only UK recruitment SEO consultancy founded by a former recruiter. Connect with Dan on LinkedIn.

Want these faults found and fixed for you? The K60 sprint includes a technical audit and fixes, analytics and conversion tracking, and five rebuilt money pages, delivered in 60 days.